eyelets have been a part of all of our lives since birth. remember some of those first pairs of shoes? yeah, eyelets held your shoelaces.
great little marvels, eyelets.
here’s some info on eyelets and setting tools, and what progress has been made over the years in terms of eyelet setting. much easier now than back in the day, that’s for sure.
check out this non-industrial eyelet/snap setter, which was probably used to add eyelets or snaps to children’s clothing. maybe craft projects too. but you’d be really limited where you could place the eyelets, because the tool would reach only ¾’ in from any edge, be it paper, leather or cloth. although the setter itself was virtually silent, i could practically hear the groans of the user as (s)he squeezed the tool with all their strength to set an eyelet or snap. oh, if one could only put an eyelet anywhere one chose, and with ease…
welcome to the 1990’s
hello leather hole punch, self-healing mat, hammer, and eyelet setter! now i can set an eyelet anywhere! only problem was that the smaller the eyelet, the more difficult it was to find a smaller punch and setter. this type of eyelet setting was noisy, but long gone were the days of the ¾” edge restriction. many crafters started using eyelets at this point because of this newer, “easier” method.
i remember banging away on eyelets with my hammer long into the night and the honey saying from the bedroom, “can you maybe set those eyelets in the morning?!?” bless my sweet man’s patient soul.
before too long, martha stewart came out with an eyelet setting tool kit, which of course i had to snatch up. then Making Memories introduced their eyelet setting tools and 3/8” eyelets in 20+ colors. Screw you, martha, and your wishy washy silver, gold and copper eyelets. although still noisy, i still held out hope and would often tell the honey, “why can’t they just come out with something that is quieter and easier on the hands…like a hole punch, but for eyelet setting?”
yeah, if i had a dollar for every time i had a thought for “they”. millions, i say. millions.
the new-and-improved versions
about five or six years ago, there was a great jump in the evolution of eyelet setting. three companies introduced a single setting tool that eliminated the need for a punch tool, setting tool and hammer. good on them, I say, and if you’re not ready to part with your clikit, instant setter or silent setter for a crop-a-dile, then don’t. keep it, and get a crop-a-dile too!
if you’re in the market for an eyelet setting tool, here’s the lowdown on the clikit, instant setter, and the silent setter:
karen foster design – clikit
this is a spring-action tool that punches holes, sets eyelets and embosses with a simple handle push.


the clikit releases about the same amount of pressure as a hammer, but with a little less noise. it comes with 10 interchangeable tips, two sets of different sized eyelets and a setting pad in a slide-top wooden box.

if punching letters into metal is your thing, additional embossing alphabets are available with complete instructions and diagrams included in the box. nifty.
making memories – instant setter

the instant setter is spring-loaded, tension-adjustable, easy on the hands and a little less loud than the clikit. it does still make some noise, so don’t get all excited. the instant setter comes with three interchangeable punching tips (1/16”, 1/8” and 3/16”), four setting tips and a setting mat, which is all neatly tucked into a metal box.

the handle is comfortable to hold and use, and each letter die from the stamping die set fits easily into the tool head. simple to follow instructions on the back of the package.
provo craft – silent setter

a quiet eyelet setter…no noise, and ergonomically designed. but like anything “ergonomically designed”, it can take some time for your body to adjust to a new way of doing things. doesn’t screw up the shape of the back of your metal eyelets the way some other setting tools can. the set includes a zippered case with a setting mat, three punch tips and three setting tips in micro, standard and large.

all you need is a medium to firm push downward and a slight rotation of the tool to securely attach an eyelet to any layout or craft project.

works best on aluminum eyelets.
crop-a-dile

if you don’t yet have a crop-a-dile, stop waiting. durable, easy to use, quiet, feels good in your hands, and you can set eyelets all night without waking your partner. works on paper, leather, plastic, metal, chipboard, acrylic, fabric, and wood.
only down-side to the original crop-a dile is that you can’t reach the center of your pages or projects…it can only punch about 3” in from the edges. for most projects this is fine, but if you do need to reach the middle, you’ll need one of the other tools as well or the newfangled long-reach version of the crop-a-dile called the “big bite”.
again, a point i made to my honey one day…“why don’t they make one where you can reach further into the middle of the page?” i swear there are product designers following me and stealing my product ideas.

this bad boy even works on metal pails!
in sum
like most inventions, each new product solves a different problem posed by its predecessor. still can’t decide what to do? here’s some thoughts:
if you’ve got an old gripper tool, keep it because it sets an industrial snap, and most newer products don’t.
if you’ve got some of the early making memories tools (or those from other companies), why not donate them to a local school for student use? that’d be most appreciated.
consider purchasing the karen foster clickit because it will easily set non-aluminum, heavier eyelets, it has many tip options, and cool alphabet embossing options.
consider the making memories instant setter for its simplicity, comfortable handle and great box.
purchase the provo craft silent setter IF you’re looking for something quiet without a lot of bells and whistles. just remember it won’t sent heavy-duty eyelets, so you may eventually end up purchasing something else that does.
purchase the crop-a-dile. this handy tool punches through just about any material and it’s easy to use.